• HILITE NEWS HAS BEEN NAMED A NATIONAL SCHOLASTIC PRESS ASSOCIATION ONLINE PACEMAKER FINALIST
  • HILITE NEWS HAS BEEN NAMED THE HOOSIER STAR WINNER FOR NEWS SITE
  • HILITE NEWS HAS BEEN NAMED A COLUMBIA SCHOLASTIC PRESS ASSOCIATION GOLD CROWN WINNER
Your source for CHS news

HiLite

Your source for CHS news

HiLite

Your source for CHS news

HiLite

Teachers should be held accountable for job performance

By Michelle Hu
<[email protected]>

There are quite a few successful Michelles in the world now – Kwan, the figure skater; Wie, the golfer; Obama, the First Lady; and now, Rhee, the educative administrator. She’s the current chancellor of Washington D.C. schools, and has almost completely shifted the blame from financing to teacher competence.

She’s absolutely crazy. In the approximate year-and-a-half that she’s been in her position, she’s closed 21 of the 143 schools she oversees, fired more than 100 staff members, 270 teachers and 36 principals. She even dismissed the principal of her own daughters’ elementary school.

She’s also brilliant. She’s revolutionized the art of school administration. Granted, she’s quite lucky. Rhee has the best bureaucratic support in the form of Adrian Fenty, mayor of D.C. Every move she’s made has been backed by Fenty, giving her carte blanche in anything she wishes to accomplish.

Her plan? To rid the system of adult incompetence. This has angered teachers’ unions across the nation, but her actions could actually make a difference. She’s beginning to treat teachers like any other professional in the free market: their paychecks are dependent upon job performance.

At this school, teachers receive an average salary of $51,078 based upon experience and college degrees earned. Job performance plays little to no role in determining this number.

In the real world, this determination raises serious concern. Surgeons are rated by their successes and lack of patient deaths. Salespeople receive commission based upon the quantitative sales they make. Why then, aren’t teachers held to the same standard?

Rhee’s plan hopes to answer this question with a powerful, resounding “they should be.” All of the staff members that she’s fired so far are ones that she has deemed incompetent, and the remaining teachers’ job performance are constantly evaluated. She’s given them a deal: keep job security or trade it for a double salary. This treads upon the greatest fears teachers feel, which is why unions are up in arms about the whole situation.

It’s not at all unreasonable. Basically, Rhee’s asking teachers to prove their worth, which, in a corporate world, is the only way to survive. Granted, a school system is far from a corporate environment, but this way of survival may just work.

However, Rhee still has problems to iron out. It is difficult to appoint a watchdog, and even if she does, there is no measurable standard to account for external factors. Factors such as classroom demographics, course level and parent involvement can all raise or lower scores significantly.

So far, Rhee has been successful. Under more capable educators, the district’s test scores have risen 8 to 11 percent in both elementary and high schools.

Rhee’s plan is admirable. She’s fought powerful unions and legislators (since Democrats are in support of teachers’ unions) in order to achieve measurable progress. With such backing from the mayor and with a keen sense of business politics, she’s inherited the perfect opportunity to reform. I can only hope that other districts follow in her example. Michelle Hu is a News editor for the HiLite. Contact her at [email protected].

View Comments (6)
Donate to HiLite
$20
$500
Contributed
Our Goal

Comments (6)

All HiLite Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • J

    Jose GironJan 26, 2009 at 8:58 am

    This a very good article because the person that wrote this article knew what they were talk about.

    Reply
  • M

    ManamiJan 26, 2009 at 8:56 am

    I really agree with you because we have few teachers who got fired. I believe that teacher should be a model of adult. If teachers did something bad in elementary school, student will think it is a good thing to do. If the teachers hold accountable for job performance, they will be good teachers more than now. I hope teachers will hold acoountable for job performance.

    Reply
  • C

    Carissa BellewJan 26, 2009 at 8:51 am

    I agree with Rhee’s plan. Why should teachers be treated the same way others are treated in the coporate world? I think it’s a great idea to evaluate teachers.

    Reply
  • D

    Dinesh NidamarthyJan 26, 2009 at 8:46 am

    I read your report.I really agreed what you said.Rhee is a great educative administrator.Rhee plan is admirable.She’s fought unions and legislators.She really did good job.I really enjoyed reading this article.

    Reply
  • S

    Shadi AhwaziJan 26, 2009 at 8:42 am

    I read your colum and I agree with Michelle Rhee.

    Reply
  • C

    Coty MJan 26, 2009 at 8:32 am

    I really liked this article it was intresting story. It is so shocking that she would actually do that.

    Reply