By Shireen Korkzan
<[email protected]>
As a ’90’s kid, I was raised with Disney’s 2D animation. Today’s children only know CG animation and vaguely remember “Home on the Range,” the last, and absolutely horrific, 2D animated film Disney ever made. Disney has lost its touch since its 2000 release of “The Emperor’s New Groove.” And like every other disappointed child from an older generation, I was ecstatic to hear about the newest and first African-American Disney princess, Princess Tiana. She will star in Disney’s newest 2D animated film, “The Princess and the Frog,” which will be released on Dec. 11.
This movie, a Broadway-style fairy tale set in the French Quarter of New Orleans, has been receiving criticism from its announcement nearly two years ago. In the original plot, the heroine’s name was Princess Maddy, which was perceived as a stereotypical working class “slave name.” Princess Maddy was also oriProxy-Connection: keep-alive Cache-Control: max-age=0 nally a maid wProxy-Connection: keep-alive Cache-Control: max-age=0 king for a rich white person, which was viewed as racially insensitive when being considered with its setting. AftProxy-Connection: keep-alive Cache-Control: max-age=0 so many complaints, Disney changed both the names of the movie and heroine as well as the setting. Princess Tiana also turned into a waitress. This in itself is already ridiculous since the original setting would have been accurate to recent history and the main character would have been more of a protagonist. But after all these changes, the public kept complaining about one minor detail.
The prince is white.
It is ironic to think that after bending so far backwards to appease people by modernizing much its newest princess’ character and setting that Disney is receiving criticism about not remaining traditional when it comes to whom Princess Tiana chooses to fall in love with. Interracial relationships were considered “uncalled for” as recently as 40 years ago; today, hardly anyone notices whom he or she is dating racially. All Disney did was reflect this in “The Princess and the Frog” with its updated main character, and it’s absolutely hypocritical for people to criticize Princess Tiana for not following a contemporarily irrelevant paradigm.
Why is it that after Americans have supposedly turned “colorblind” about different skin colors, and we finally voted the first candidate born from an interracial relationship into presidential office, they would find this unacceptable in a family movie? If anything, parents should be proud of Disney for including diversity in its films. The Wonderful World of Disney’s 1997 television film “Cinderella,” starring Brandy and a plethora of award-winning actors, received numerous accolades for its immense diversity. Cinderella is black, her prince is Asian, the Queen is black and the King is white. No child ever pointed his or her fingers and said, “That’s not possible!” Instead, he or she probably didn’t even notice and sang along with Cinderella. It’s incredibly hard to believe there is such criticism 12 years later, when more people are or have been involved in interracial relationships. If anything, children need to be more exposed to society’s latest trend.
There is nothing wrong with being involved in an interracial relationship. A few paradigms may need to change, but they don’t determine the person. Parents need to teach this to their children at a young age so that they can grow up only seeing gray. Princess Tiana and Prince Naveen may be the easiest (and most fun) way to surreptitiously expose young people to interracial relationships. Shireen Korkzan is a writing coach for the HiLite. Contact her at [email protected].
Maddy not Mammy • May 21, 2009 at 1:10 am
It’s interesting that you talk about how Tiana’s original job as a maid is accurate for it’s time era. I don’t really remember Beauty and the Beast’s Belle being very accurate, seeing as she wasn’t shacked up with a husband taking care of multiple kids, even though that would have been “accurate” at her time period. What about Jasmine being single and apparently quite the dresser, when being “accurate'” to her era, she would be much more clothed and betrothed. There’s so much fantasy and inaccuracies in Disney movies that changing her position from an insensitive maid to a waitress isn’t much to ask. Imagine the uproar if Cinderella’s evil step mother was black and Cinderella was to be slaving away for her.
Secondly, when has there ever, ever, ever, ever been a interracial marriage in an animated Disney movie? Really? Why does it start now, with the black princess. As the product of multiple interracial marriages, the fact that you say “today, hardly anyone notices whom he or she is dating racially” is horribly naive and borderline insulting. It is not nearly as you say as being a certain color or speaking a certain way automatically turns off many many people. So, even if more people are doing it than before, it is still far from “hardly” anyone not doing it.